random ramblings

sometimes useless nothings, sometimes brilliant thoughts

Friday, January 07, 2005

Movie review

So here it is, my personal review of The Phantom of the Opera movie. Please know that I have had an obsession with the stage version in my teen years, read the book, studied the lyrics and saw it 10 times at the Pantages theatre in Toronto. So I am picky... but was hopeful and excited to see the film version.

My major complaints are:
* Way too Harliquin-esque and had batman-like cape flapping shots
* All of a sudden when brought to the Phantom's lair, Christine had on dark eye shadow and was showing her garter - very tacky.
* Raul was wearing a leather trench coat, I am no fashion historian but I was very distracted by it because it did not seem appropriate.
*The Phantom placed Christine on a black horse to lead her down a small ramp, that was so stupid.
* There was an unnecessary abuse scene of the Phantom as a child, poorly done.
* They tried way too hard to make it romantic and mystical and ended up making it cheesy.

In conclusion:
The music stands alone and anyone who does not get the shivers hearing the opening score has no nerve endings, my sister sobbed at the end, and I will buy the DVD (sometimes we all need a little cheese in our lives).

2 Comments:

  • At Friday, January 07, 2005 3:13:00 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    I saw 'Finding Neverland' with Elana, and sobbed the WHOLE way through. So add it to your list! J

     
  • At Sunday, January 09, 2005 7:28:00 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    The review from Jane -
    Interview with the Vampie: cheesy but sexy. The Haunted Mansion at Disney world: cheesy but fun. This elaborate, bosom-heaving film adaptation of Andrew Lloyd Webber's Phantom of the Opera: just plain cheesy.

    J

     

Post a Comment

<< Home

 
Free Hit Counter
Gap Coupons