Movie review
So here it is, my personal review of The Phantom of the Opera movie. Please know that I have had an obsession with the stage version in my teen years, read the book, studied the lyrics and saw it 10 times at the Pantages theatre in Toronto. So I am picky... but was hopeful and excited to see the film version.
My major complaints are:
* Way too Harliquin-esque and had batman-like cape flapping shots
* All of a sudden when brought to the Phantom's lair, Christine had on dark eye shadow and was showing her garter - very tacky.
* Raul was wearing a leather trench coat, I am no fashion historian but I was very distracted by it because it did not seem appropriate.
*The Phantom placed Christine on a black horse to lead her down a small ramp, that was so stupid.
* There was an unnecessary abuse scene of the Phantom as a child, poorly done.
* They tried way too hard to make it romantic and mystical and ended up making it cheesy.
In conclusion:
The music stands alone and anyone who does not get the shivers hearing the opening score has no nerve endings, my sister sobbed at the end, and I will buy the DVD (sometimes we all need a little cheese in our lives).
My major complaints are:
* Way too Harliquin-esque and had batman-like cape flapping shots
* All of a sudden when brought to the Phantom's lair, Christine had on dark eye shadow and was showing her garter - very tacky.
* Raul was wearing a leather trench coat, I am no fashion historian but I was very distracted by it because it did not seem appropriate.
*The Phantom placed Christine on a black horse to lead her down a small ramp, that was so stupid.
* There was an unnecessary abuse scene of the Phantom as a child, poorly done.
* They tried way too hard to make it romantic and mystical and ended up making it cheesy.
In conclusion:
The music stands alone and anyone who does not get the shivers hearing the opening score has no nerve endings, my sister sobbed at the end, and I will buy the DVD (sometimes we all need a little cheese in our lives).
2 Comments:
At Friday, January 07, 2005 3:13:00 PM, Anonymous said…
I saw 'Finding Neverland' with Elana, and sobbed the WHOLE way through. So add it to your list! J
At Sunday, January 09, 2005 7:28:00 AM, Anonymous said…
The review from Jane -
Interview with the Vampie: cheesy but sexy. The Haunted Mansion at Disney world: cheesy but fun. This elaborate, bosom-heaving film adaptation of Andrew Lloyd Webber's Phantom of the Opera: just plain cheesy.
J
Post a Comment
<< Home